Reynolds v. United States was a mishandling of justice. Banning polygamy actually is a violation of the establishment clause. You don’t get to pick and choose what aspects of a religion you are outlawing. That’s still the state establishing religion by suppressing some religions but not others. If the government can pick and chose what aspects of a religion it wants to ban then in essence you have a de facto establishment of religion. For example, banning entheogens is a de facto ban on traditional religions which have used them ritualistically for much longer than this country existed.
Given that entheogens have been used by shamans, witches and other magical practitioners since before the dawn of human civilization, the war on drugs is literally a modern-day continuation of the witch hunts. It’s a war on spiritual awakening and a war on personal freedom, despite whatever propaganda they regurgitate. It’s a modern day inquisition.
Discrimination motivated by religion is a form of religious discrimination. It is therefore a violation of the establishment clause to pass any law that is religiously motivated. Examples include abortion bans, the war on drugs, the ban on polygamy, any attempts to criminalize homosexuality or trans identity. It’s all just establishing parts of the Christian religion as the law of the land. There is no meaningful difference between saying “you can practice your religion but only in the ways we say you’re allowed to” and saying “you can’t practice your religion.”
To put this into terms that might be more obvious to people, especially those with a Christian background, lets use the inverse example. Indigenous cultures in America have long held a taboo against any form of cannibalism, ritualistically simulated or otherwise. This is because it was well known to cause a condition known regionally by different names such as wetiko sickness, wendigo possession, etc. The Eucharist ritual in Christianity is a form of ritualized cannibalism. If the tables were turned and it was the indigenous Americans who were the dominant socio-economic group of society (like they would have been if they weren’t systematically eradicated by the Christian settlers) then they could make a pretty well reasoned argument to ban the core ritual of the Christian religion for being incredibly dangerous. Of course Christians would rightfully scream about that being a form of religious discrimination, but they could just make the same idiotic arguments used to justify the Reynolds v. United States ruling, or any ruling about the indigenous use of entheogenic compounds to justify it and under this precedent the Christians would have no recourse but to abandon one of their core rituals. This would of course be immoral.
Therefore, all government suppression of any aspect of established religions including the ritual usage of entheogenic compounds and the practice of polygamy is a direct violation of the establishment clause no matter what nonsense the judges made up to justify it.
We have learned absolutely nothing from the burning times. We’re repeating the same mistakes ad infinitum. Honestly I think they secretly know this and know they would get called out on their hypocrisy, because the entheogens used by the witches during the burning times, (Devil’s’ Eye, Devil’s Cherries and Devil’s Apple¹), are legal despite being much more dangerous if misused than a lot of the entheogens still widely banned such as psilocybin. Of course this isn’t a call to ban them too, but rather to stop the witch hunt.
Now for some of these compounds, I can see some kind of argument for restricting who has access to them to the initiated (i.e. clergy, witches, shamans, etc) so only those who know what they’re doing can use them, but how something like that should be determined and who gets to decide what religious institutions are valid is fraught with problems at best and so is probably a bad idea.
Obviously not all drugs have a history of entheogenic use. A lot of the synthetic drugs invented by the CIA during MK ULTRA and the ones invented by the FBI and introduced into minority populations as an excuse to arrest them are extremely dangerous and harmful and should probably stay illegal to sell. However people addicted to them should be treated as medical patients, not as criminals. After all, many of them are simply self-medicating psychological issues since actual psychological care is largely unavailable for the lower class in this country and is still in its infancy as a science. Not every condition has a prescription cure. However, even if it doesn’t have a documented history of entheogenic use, that doesn’t mean it wouldn’t make a great entheogen. Synthetic DMT doesn’t have a history of entheogenic use, but is one of the best entheogens out there. After all, it’s the active ingredient in ayahuasca. Therefore, even trying to pick and chose what can and cannot be used is fraught with problems that would have to be navigated with the involvement of the spiritual communities that use these compounds and the opinion of those outside those communities shouldn’t even be entertained.
It’s also important to remember that the kind of hierarchical legal institution of religious organizations that we see building churches and the like is an organization antithetical to the way these more traditional religions express themselves. The witches² of old didn’t have a formal church where they gathered, nature itself was their church. Sacred groves, sacred mountains, sacred rivers, etc were never controlled in the hierarchical way that churches are. Therefore the legal requirements for recognition as an official religion by the US Government is again a violation of the establishment clause. It’s absurd to expect every practicing witch to have to provide a “recognized creed and form of worship”, “definite and distinct form of church governance” etc. That’s simply not how these older forms of religion ever operated. These rules exist explicitly to deny older forms of religion access to the same rights given to the Abrahamic religions and religions able to mimic the Abrahamic hierarchical form of organization. They are in themselves a form of religious discrimination.
¹Note: The entheogens listed here are named using herbal code to prevent the uninitiated from experimenting with them without the proper training. They are extremely dangerous if misused.
²Note: I’m using the term witch here as a catch-all term to describe the religious leaders of any of the pre-Christian European religious groups specifically because they were the ones targeted during the burning times, despite the fact that almost none of them would have used that term preferring instead terms like cunning folk, seiðr, druid, etc.
